The Best First Toys for Babies (That Aren’t Overstimulating)

As a new parent, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed by the endless sea of baby toys—flashing lights, loud songs, and gadgets that promise to teach your baby everything under the sun by six months.

But here’s a little secret: your baby doesn’t need all that.

In fact, in those early months, the best toys are the simplest ones.

What Makes a Great First Toy?

In the first 0–6 months of life, babies are just beginning to explore the world around them. They’re learning through their senses—touch, sound, sight, and eventually, taste. The right toy at this stage doesn’t need to be complicated. It just needs to be:

• Safe for grasping and mouthing
• Stimulating, but not overwhelming
• Easy to hold with tiny hands
• Supportive of early sensory development

And, if we’re honest—bonus points if it can fit in a diaper bag and survive the washing machine.

Why Sensory Toys Are a Great Place to Start

Sensory play isn’t just fun—it’s foundational. A crinkle here, a texture there, a new sound from squeezing or chewing... these are your baby’s earliest lessons in cause and effect, self-soothing, and coordination.

Simple sensory toys like soft crinkle squares or fabric teethers are often favorites because they do just that—without overstimulating your baby or your home.

What to Look For in a Sensory Toy

When you’re picking that first toy (or baby shower gift!), look for:

• Crinkle sounds – great for auditory development
• Soft fabrics – gentle on baby’s skin and safe to chew
• Compact size – easy to hold, carry, and clean
• Neutral or high-contrast colors – especially helpful for newborn vision

Keep It Simple. Keep It Meaningful.

Your baby doesn’t need flashing lights or four language modes. They need you—and simple tools that help them explore at their own pace.

If you’re looking for that one toy to calm, engage, and spark curiosity from the very beginning, keep it small. Keep it soft. Keep it sensory.

(And yes, we happen to know a great one.)